- Home
- Policy and infrastructure
- Crate Bikes Clog Up Station Bike Parking
Crate Bikes Clog Up Station Bike Parking

Many station bike parking facilities now see a growing number of crate bikes, or bikes with baskets at the front, and this causes problems for their managers. These so-called “oversized bikes” (buitenmodelfietsen) often do not fit the standard racks and lead to overcrowded parking. A study by CROW-Fietsberaad, the Dutch knowledge platform for cycling, carried out for NS (Dutch Railways) and ProRail, shows that the problem is only growing.
The Problem of Oversized Bikes
Oversized bikes are bikes that differ from the standard dimensions the racks in station parking are designed for. About one in three bikes falls into this category. It is not only about crate bikes or bikes with baskets, but also bikes with panniers, thicker tyres, wider handlebars and more weight.
There are also bikes such as cargo bikes and recumbent bikes, which take up considerably more space because of their size and shape. At the moment, cargo bikes and recumbents are not yet a big problem in the stations studied. Even so, they have specific parking needs. A cargo bike, for example, always needs a separate space.
Crate Bikes
Crate bikes are especially popular with commuters and students, who use them to carry shopping and other things. They are handy. However, these bikes often take up more space than traditional bikes. A bike with a crate or child seat often blocks access to other bike spaces in the parking. For example, a bike with a child seat in the lower tier of a two-tier rack can block the pull-out rail of the rack above. As a result, other users park their bikes at random, which adds to the chaos in the parking.
Panniers
Panniers cause a similar problem. They make bikes wider, so they do not fit well in standard racks. This makes the neighbouring spaces hard or impossible to use. Bikes with bags often hang over the edges of their allotted space, which causes space problems.
Solutions from CROW-Fietsberaad
To tackle the problem of oversized bikes, CROW-Fietsberaad proposes pilots with different types of bike spaces: “compact spaces”, “plus spaces” and “double-plus spaces”. The aim is to give more flexibility and space to the many types of bikes now in use.
Plus Spaces and Double-Plus Spaces
- Plus spaces: These offer more room per bike space, but are in less convenient places in the parking. This should discourage users from taking up more space than they need, while still letting them park their bigger bikes.
- Double-plus spaces: Users pay more for these spaces, but they also get a better location and more room. This can appeal to people who use their bike often and want to be sure of a good space.
Exactly what these plus spaces will look like has still to be worked out. Options include parking spaces like those in some guarded parking for mopeds and scooters, or new special oversized racks that are now on the market.
Responsibility and the Future
The responsibility for tackling this problem does not lie only with the parking facilities. Cyclists must also think about the space they take up. It is important to find solutions that are efficient and do justice to the needs of all cyclists.
By introducing innovative solutions such as plus spaces, we can make bike parking future-proof. This is crucial, as bike use keeps growing and the variety of bike types increases. It is up to all of us to help create a liveable and accessible environment for every cyclist.