Who Pays for Damage After a Collision with an Electric Bike?

Vergoeding bij aanrijding elektrische fietsen

Who pays for the damage after a collision with an electric bike?

Last week, the Volkskrant headlined that cyclists now top the list of fatal traffic accidents for the first time. This rise is mainly due to the growing popularity of the electric bike. Figures from CBS (Statistics Netherlands) show that a quarter of those cyclists who died were riding an electric bike. Because the law sees cyclists and pedestrians as weaker road users, it protects them. That means that after a collision, drivers must always pay for the damage to the cyclist or pedestrian. But does this also apply in an electric bike collision?
Legal protection

Road Traffic Act (Wegenverkeerswet)

The law (Article 185 of the Road Traffic Act) says that as the driver of a motor vehicle you are always strictly liable, so you must pay for the damage to the pedestrian or cyclist. The law exists to protect weaker road users: as a cyclist or pedestrian, you simply run a greater risk of serious injury because of the mass of the motor vehicle. The exception is force majeure, but in practice it is almost never granted.
Speed pedelecs not protected by the law

To decide who is liable in an electric bike collision between a driver and a rider, we need to distinguish between two kinds of electric bike: the standard electric bike and the speed pedelec.

Standard electric bike

Features:

  • no number plate required
  • pedal assistance
  • you have to pedal to move forward
  • electric motor with a maximum power of 250 watts
  • maximum speed 25 km/h

Which rules apply?

  • there is no minimum age
  • you must ride on the cycle path
  • no driving licence needed
  • third-party liability insurance (WA) is not compulsory

You can find everything about the rules for your electric bike on the website of the government.

Speed pedelec

Features

  • a yellow number plate
  • maximum speed 45 km/h
  • moped driving licence compulsory
  • rear-view mirror
  • electric motor with a power between 250 and 4,000 watts

Which rules apply?

  • 30 km/h on the moped path in built-up areas
  • 40 km/h on the moped path outside built-up areas
  • 45 km/h on the road
  • helmet compulsory
  • minimum age of 16
  • compulsory third-party liability insurance (WA)
  • moped driving licence compulsory
You can find everything about the rules for your speed pedelec on the website of the government.

Notably, the legal protection only applies to electric bikes where you have to pedal to move forward. In other words, the law sees these standard electric bikes as weaker road users and protects them. Legally, speed pedelecs count as mopeds. So this protective law does not apply to them.

How this affects you as an electric bike rider

This has quite a few consequences for your liability as a cyclist. Suppose you are involved in a collision. And you were riding a speed pedelec. Then the law does not see you as a weaker road user, and you count as a moped rider. In that case, you have the same rights and duties as a driver.
Only on a standard electric bike do you get at least 50% of the damage paid by the car owner’s car insurance. How much you owe exactly differs per situation, and depends on things like the damage forms, witnesses and other evidence. Children under 14 always get 100% of the damage paid by the driver’s car insurer.

Which insurance do I need with an electric bike?

As an electric bike rider. Do you ride a speed pedelec? Then the law does not protect you. Because you are still a vulnerable road user, you must take out third-party liability insurance (WA) for your bike. For a standard electric bike, you can insure yourself with personal liability insurance (AVP).

As a driver. Fortunately, your car insurance covers the damage you cause to others. It makes no difference whether you have third-party, limited comprehensive or fully comprehensive cover. Is the cyclist at fault? Then most insurers do not take it out of your claim-free years. If you are at fault as a driver and you claim the damage, you drop back five claim-free years. As a result, you fall down the bonus-malus ladder and get less no-claims discount. So the premium of your car insurance will rise.

High damage costs because of expensive car parts and bikes

In a collision involving an electric bike rider, the chance of personal injury is higher. After all, cyclists are very vulnerable road users. Personal injury is expensive damage, and the process often takes a long time as well. In addition, new cars and electric bikes often have expensive parts. So keep in mind that the damage amount (and the time it takes) can rise a lot.

Choose your language